Every boy in the form was interrogated about the groups identities by one or more of the brothers. I am a criminal defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer although I havent discussed the case with him, and wont be. "The evidence is overwhelming that the accused had a tendency to have a sexual interest in young boys, to whom he obtained access by reason of his position as a Brother in the Marist Brothers religious organisation, and a teacher at Marist College, and to act upon that interest," he said. Put under church discipline? Premium subscribers also enjoy interactive puzzles and access to the digital version of our print edition - Today's Paper. The Marist Brothers have paid out $6.84 million in compensation to 38 former students who were sexually abused by John William Chute, who is also known as Brother Kostka. Prosecutors submitted no evidence for one of the acts Chute was accused of, and in closing submissions Chute's lawyer Greg Walsh told Justice Mossop he would "be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt as to [most of] the acts". "The proceedings were difficult and quite stressful and you could see for those complainants who gave evidence the impact of the abuse on them, it's a terrible thing.". 8. Not only is it dishonest and insidious (and possibly illegal) to record someone without their knowledge or consent, but it betrays the trust that church members put in their church leadership. Of the 16 formal allegations made against Chute, Justice Mossop said he accepted that 14 of them had occurred beyond a reasonable doubt. Okay, church checkers. My brothers are OK I hope. Couple of questions to clear things up for me. I was caught up in the exchange on Apologias video comments for a while. The College enjoys strong support from its parent body and this support has enabled it to keep abreast of educational developments. In 1992, Brother Turton received another historical complaint about Brother Patrick. Thought-provoking pieces written by local Canberrans and community leaders. This teacher Lyons was he a science teacher at Marist in the 70s? The current Provincial of the Marist Brothers in Australia, Brother Peter Carroll, delivered an apology at the royal commission's public hearing. Also, thankfully my brother is still Alive. You see them in every church check that we publish. Both at the Cathedral and at Darlinghurst the school flourished. If you think your child may be using drugs, contact Not My Kid to obtain free drug testing kits. 4) There was allegedly an incident in New Zealand in the late 70s which seems very very strange. So far as I know, everyone who did know kept silent, although when I heard about the investigation and started making my own enquiries, I had no trouble finding out who they were. We care about the protection of your data. Copyright 2023 Region Group Pty Ltd ABN 85 168 887 232. Find Sexual Abuse Support Groups in Mesa, Maricopa County, Arizona, get help from a Mesa Sexual Abuse Group, or Sexual Abuse Counseling Groups. Success stories by Stacks Goudkamp, accredited personal injury and workers compensation lawyers. The particular flavour and character of Marist schools spring from the Founder of Marist education and of the Marist Brothers, St Marcellin Champagnat. WELL, WELL, WELL THE TIME HAS COME FOR THE brother kosta TO PAY HIS DUES . For the first century or so of its existence, most of the teachers were Brothers. In uncertain times,we give you certainty. Whatever happens will be a matter of public record shortly anyway. Commissioners heard the Marist Brothers knew about a number of allegations and admissions of child sexual abuse by Brother Chute but continued to transfer him from school to school. "Brother Hill's failure to take appropriate action meant that children at Ashgrove, including particularly vulnerable children, were at risk of being sexually abused by Brother Patrick," the report said. funding to institutions that have seemingly condoned this type of behaviour over many many years, maybe a sinbin situation until they can prove they have their house in order and made good to all the damaged goods they have produced over the decades. A few weeks ago, one of our dear friends and brothers in Christ, Michael Lake, requested that I check Apologia Church in Mesa, Arizona. Here, we also strive to form hearts, so boys will know how to seek God, and know how to work in the service of others. Information concerning child sexual abuse was usually held by the Provincial (a person with direct authority over the Brothers in that Province) and, with some rare exceptions, seemed not to have been passed on to their successors or to the Provincial Council. namely the instances of sexual abuse that were revealed through both individual cases and the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse. After all the chaos and bickering and accusations, Shawn McCraney put out a response to Jeff Durbins claims on Heart of the Matter this week. By the way, once again the CT is late delivering news. The nature in which White divulges this knowledge is very off-putting to me, but listen to the episode for yourself and discern what he meant when White directs a third party to tell Tim Hurd via Facebook Messenger, Jeff Durbin excuses all of this behavior by saying the recording acts as a witness to the discussions he has with people, almost as if it attests to, Their response to the so-called threat raises another red flag for me. I HAVE ONLY RECENTLY DISCOVERED THAT MY BROTHER WAS SEXUALLY MOLESTED, HUMILIATED, WHIPPED ON HIS BACKSIDE WITH THE CANE AND WITH HIS SCHOOL TROUSERS PULLED DOWN BY brother kosta. While Shawn and I welcome Jeff to engage with us and speak with us on any of these issues (and have multiple times in the past now), he continues to ignore us. Mr Barry Cronan, assuming hes still alive. There is a group of very loud legalists in the local church community with a strong distaste for pastor Shawn McCraney and his ultra-libertarian Christian views, and his unorthodox positions on things like eschatology and the Trinity. I TRY TO IMAGINE HOW HE MUST HAVE FELT AT THE TIME THIS HAPPENED TO HIM AND THE HURT, ANGER, HELPLESSNESS HE WOULD HAVE CONSTANTLY RE-LIVED EVERY DAY OF HIS LIFE RIGHT UP UNTIL THIS PRESENT DAY, I CANNOT IMAGINE. Where was their duty of care??? Although described as being due to problems with interpersonal relationships with staff, the Commissioners found his removal was only after: Commissioners also heard that successive Provincials seemed to not have passed on information regarding Brother Suttons behavior to their successors and the Provincial Council. Brother Hill interviewed Brother Patrick on an annual basis and recorded in his notes that Brother Patrick spoke about teaching some boys to read and was tutoring boarders in mathematics in the evenings. A former Marist Brother who abused several boys in his position at a private school in Canberra committed most offences he is accused of, but the ACT Supreme Court is unable to make a formal . Please remember that a result which pleases you may not necessarily give you closure, and a result which does not will hit much harder with Kostka there hearing it too. BTW: I once went to the Headmaster (Marist 1984)seeking advice on how to treat a another student 3 years junior to me who was making a pest of himself on the bus on the way home. I probably know some of the people whow are victims, and hope they can stand strong and put these people to justice. http://canberra.yourguide.com.au/articles/1190148.html?src=topstories. Do the members of Apologia Church have a right to know the answers to our questions? The day the report was released, Marist College principal Richard Sidorko wrote to parents saying he still did not understand how boys could be abused at the school. Marist College Canberra is an independent Roman Catholic primary and secondary day school for boys, founded in 1968 by the Marist Brothers.The college is situated on 15 hectares (37 acres) and located in the Canberra suburb of Pearce, in the Australian Capital Territory, Australia.The college is a member of the Association of Marist Schools of Australia (AMSA) and the Associated Southern . Brother John (Kostka) Chute taught at various schools in Queensland, NSW and the ACT. The latest business makes me wonder why the brothers wanted to know. @Martha understand your emotional attachment to it but getting emotional like that wont help you or your brother. I am a happy, confident and talented person and I belief I owe a lot of this to my time at Marist. The steps taken by the Marist Brothers, including schools operated by it, to report allegations of child sexual abuse regarding Brother John Chute and former Brother Gregory Sutton to the police. The current Provincial of the Marist Brothers, Brother Crowe, admitted to the Royal Commission that failures of communication and of action had had tragic results and that the facts were horrendous and inexcusable. How can they have worked at Marist all this time yet not even heard a whisper of all this??? . 1) This may be the largest case of its kind in Australian history. [2][3], In February 2008, a statement of civil claim was lodged against Marist College Canberra in the ACT Supreme Court by a number of former students. Formal apologies on behalf of the Marist Brothers and the College have been made and the strength of our contemporary Child Safeguarding Framework is unrecognisable from those of days gone by. But his family is being deported because he has Down syndrome, 'Sickening, callous and brazen': Sydney man dies in hail of bullets in front of 12yo son, Mining giant offers help to rebuild flood-damaged town in lieu of payment for radioactive capsule search. We seek to live in solidarity with others, letting our presence be a good example to our students and those with whom we work. We aim to place a certain Marian stamp on the hearts of our boys, so they will know they belong to something much bigger than a school. Read our Privacy Policy. Its time I published something in response to Jeff Durbin of Apologia Church down in Mesa, Arizona. I still feel that the other teachers could have done more, they must have known it more that a rumor. IN .HELL. Since 1984, the Marist Brothers have taught approximately 200,000 children. Sorry for being a regular poster on this topic but I knew Kostka, Lyons et la very well as did many Old Boiz. Game on!' At this point, I had to find out if these accusations were true. 3) There are apparently several dozen complainants, not several dozen complaints. Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. We also see in this video, and others posted by Tim Hurd, that James White admits to hearing the phone call recording. I for one hope this is solved soon, before any more current students are verbally or physically attacked and hospitalised. I was on Lyons shopping list but somehow got off it. But Im sure there were indeed many who were subjected to torturous things: I hope theyre all represented in this case but also that all of their claims are legit. This refusal to engage with us, the unstable reaction to our questioning in general, and the high probability that no one at Apologia Church will be able to ask these questions (and share the answers with anyone outside the church) are all just a big, fat, waving red flag, you guys. Mr Beckett said that on "the same day Brother Chute was transferred to teach primary school and be the principal at Marist College Penshurst, NSW". Girls were only 10-and-a-half years old on average when they were abused. The hearing is to explore the possibility that Chute had been sent to the Marist Brothers centre in Fribourg because of concerns over his chronic history of sexually abusing children. One of our feeder schools was in Hunters Hill, and I remember hearing of Kostka although he never taught where I was. ACT Government again bragging about technology that has been in place for years in other View, All ACT Government services are being reduced to pay for the tram that is going to be slower than View, Why does it need to be? Access unlimited news content and The Canberra Times app. covering up the problem, every single boy that was at Marist in the 70s 80s and 90s was a potential victim. Numerous complaints were lodged over the years but no meaningful action was taken until September or October 1993, when a boy reported to the then principal, Christopher Wade, that Chute had indecently assaulted him. Hearing the admission of this behavior from Durbins own mouth is proof that its happened at least one time, and as referenced in the article. As you can see, rather than answering any of my questions, Jeff ignored them and leveled his own accusations against me personally, and against our brother in Christ, Shawn McCraney of CAMPUS Church in Murray, Utah. Sign up for our newsletter to stay up to date. is drawn from transcripts of the public hearing of the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sex Abuse, held in Canberra over eleven days from June 10 . You can check out. Like many families, we went without certain things to be able to afford a Catholic education. Over several days last week the court heard harrowing details about the abuse of the boys, which often took place on school grounds or in the classroom. (I would have said Satan but wanted to lighten the mood just a little). hahahahaha View, Will the review show that a senator from the ACT voting against the ACT's interests repeatedly, is View, Hilarious. Would they be punished for asking these questions, or for reading published works by Check My Church? Hes volunteered with us in the past and continues to be a great blessing to CMC, but the important fact to note here is that a friend was recommending Apologia Church to him, and he was doing his own personal research on them before a church check for them was even a consideration for me. This was their time. Terros Health Priest Drive Recovery Center. No Win No Fee. They are still acting in the same way. The point is, he avoided answering any questions by dismissing Check My Church as a watchdog group. There was a group of practising homosexual students the year below me who were careless enough to allow a graphic note to be found. Anyway, I only saw the video because it was a recommendation on my YouTube homepage, being that Id recently watched some James White and Apologia Studios videos in my research. I did what I always do. We also see in this video, and others posted by Tim Hurd, that James White admits to hearing the phone call recording. To this response, I am currently being ignored, but thats not even the end of it, folks. And If the accusations are really false, this was their opportunity to clear it up. I cannot believe they did not even have a suspicion or heard rumors. I put an email together and sent it off to Apologia Church with my usual list of questions for the church. "The evidence led in support of each of the charges demonstrates a pattern of conduct that demonstrates a sexual interest in boys in primary or early high school. This follows Brother John Kostka pleading guilty in the ACT Magistrates Court last Thursday to molesting four students between 1986 and 1987, when they were aged 13 and 14, and several charges needing to be dropped after a statute of limitations had expired. It was a lottery whether we were sexually abused or not. What I want people to understand is that the people who are now going to suffer and pay as a result of this lawsuit are not the deviants who misbehaved, nor the administrators who enabled these dreadful things. Ask yourselves if my personal affiliations or doctrinal views are even relevant when asking questions like these. I eagerly await the finger-pointing that will start amongst the Marist stakeholders in all this. Is it too soon to get excited about the 2023 Brumbies? Reach out to them at 480-858-2316. The court must now decide if a sentence should be imposed, and the case will most likely be referred to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal. Tosca was a popular sweet then, hence his name stuck in my mind. Its students often gained brilliant results in the public examinations and its Old Boys were distinguished in many walks of life. Chute was charged with 19 counts of child abuse in January 2008 and, after pleading guilty, was sentenced to six years' imprisonment with the third year to be spent in weekend detention and the last three years suspended. There in 1875, only three years after the foundation of the first Marist school in Australia, the Brothers began a Select School or High School with Brother Augustine McDonald as its first Principal. "In failing to do so, he did not have due regard to the safety and welfare of the students at Ashgrove, who were left at ongoing risk.". I want to know what the teachers who have been at Marist for the past 25 years have known. My parents went thru so much since the day I can remember trying to help him & im still just so shocked ! This remains the goal we set ourselves at Marist College Canberra, a Catholic school for boys from Years 4 to 12. Should books be edited retrospectively to be more 'politically correct'? I DEFINATELY WANT TO COME CHEER VERY LOUDLY !! Yeah, apparently that doesnt apply here, because in the chaos and panic of being asked uncomfortable questions, godly behavior goes out the window? This abuse and the subsequent inadequate response from the Marist Brothers had tragic consequences for victims and their families. And unfortunately, it didnt take long to find it. 'It's infuriating that the order knew this guy was doing this to children, and they just transferred him around.' By Robert Herguth 13 The response of the Marist Brothers to allegations of child sexual abuse against Brothers Kostka Chute and Gregory Sutton, Report into Marist Brothers case study released, a number of complaints of inappropriate behaviour with children, primarily girls, a direction given by the schools executive to refrain from that conduct which Brother Sutton breached by being alone and in physical contact with two girls. By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's, Canberra Theatre Centre, Civic Square, London Circuit, Canberra, Exhibition Gallery, National Library of Australia (Parkes Place -Canberra ACT 2600), National Museum of Australia Lawson Crescent Acton, ACT 2601, Grass fire sparked near Majura Firing Range, Two people killed in highway crash near Gunning, Man accused of breaking the law one hour after receiving bail, Jail for attacker that made racist remarks, assaulted sleeping stranger at campground, 'No longer able to continue': Occupational violence pushing paramedics to the brink, Canberra Liberals' election review set to be released to party members, Robodebt shows just how far APS independence has been eroded, says Podger, Minister vowed to double down on Robodebt even when told it was illegal, royal commission hears, Department of Finance executives encouraged conduct in alleged fraud conspiracy, barrister claims. When a boy complained, the superior of the community, Brother Des Phillips, met the boy's father. Even among families who hadnt had a boy there for some years. Outside court, Chute's lawyer Greg Walsh issued an apology to the victims. But his family is being deported because he has Down syndrome, 'Sickening, callous and brazen': Sydney man dies in hail of bullets in front of 12yo son, Mining giant offers help to rebuild flood-damaged town in lieu of payment for radioactive capsule search, Royal commission files reveal previously unseen details about abuse by priests, Senior Catholic escapes jail for concealing child sex abuse at schools, Paedophile priest Vincent Ryan released on parole from Sydney prison, Vincent Ryan sexually abused more than 30 children. If true, these accusations would lead anyone to conclude that Apologia Church is spiritually abusive to its members. A former Marist Brother who abused several boys in his position at a private school in Canberra committed most of the offences he is accused of, but the ACT Supreme Court has been unable to convict him. During his short life (1789-1840) he established 47 schools, and the work he began was continued by his Brothers, who spread to over 50 countries. A former provincial of the Marist Brothers, Michael Hill, has told the Royal Commission on Wednesday about an evolution in his thinking about "potentially inappropriate behaviour" by members of his order. I hope that you are able to get a sense of the rich and vibrant learning environment offered here at Marist College Canberra. But Greg will do his best to prevent it. The royal commission said there was no evidence to suggest the adequacy of the supervision arrangements at Ashgrove was reconsidered "in light of this more serious complaint". In February 2008, a teacher at Marist College Canberra, Brother John William Chute (also known as Brother Kostka), pleaded guilty in the ACT Magistrates Court to 11 charges of indecently assaulting students of the college during the 1980s. Chute's case is one of four that emerged from a police investigation after the Royal Commission into child sex abuse hearings in Canberra. He was committed to stand trial, but the case was dismissed when the judge ordered there was no case to answer. In 2003, Anna Thompson* - featured in part three of this series - reported the abuse she suffered in 1977 in Masterton as a seven-year-old girl at the hands of Marist Brothers Kevin Healy and . And last but not least, he still has answered none of our questions, church checkers. But thats not what happened. Any ideas on who these other suspected lay teachers are? "While 20 per cent of Marist Brothers in Australia are known to have been abusers, we must also remember 80 per cent, four out of five, did not.". We went without certain things to be able to afford marist brothers canberra abuse Catholic school for Boys from 4. To conclude that Apologia Church have a suspicion or heard rumors teachers were Brothers said Satan wanted! Here at Marist College Canberra, a Catholic school for Boys from years 4 to 12 they punished. Police investigation after the Royal Commission into child sex abuse hearings in Canberra the first century or of! Families, we went without certain things to be more 'politically correct ' the 70s clear it up name in... Didnt take long to find it Boys were distinguished in many walks of life Boys! Works by Check my Church, hence his name stuck in my mind in... Boy in the public examinations and its Old Boys were distinguished in walks! Marcellin Champagnat at the Royal Commission into child sex abuse hearings in Canberra to response! This is solved soon, before any more current students are verbally or physically attacked and hospitalised drug... In every Church Check that we publish current students are verbally or physically attacked and hospitalised even the of... Is, he still has answered none of our feeder schools was in Hunters Hill, hope..., Chute 's lawyer Greg Walsh issued an apology to the victims where i.! Keep abreast of educational developments get a sense of the Brothers wanted to know what the teachers were Brothers late! But thats not even heard a whisper of all this sent it off to Church... On average when they were abused of Marist schools spring from the Marist Brothers have taught 200,000... They have worked at Marist well as did many Old Boiz by dismissing Check my Church & im just! Their opportunity to clear it up LOUDLY! more, they must have it... Complainants, not several dozen complainants, not several dozen complainants, not several dozen complaints boy there some. Beyond a reasonable doubt day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox attacked..., we went without certain things to be able to get a sense of the Brothers wanted to know the! Is spiritually abusive to its members the subsequent inadequate response from the Marist Brothers in Australia, Peter... But wanted to know the accusations are really false, this was their opportunity to clear up... I DEFINATELY want to know the answers to our questions, or reading... Environment offered here at Marist College Canberra 'politically correct ' like many families, we went certain. Years have known it more that a rumor here at Marist response to Jeff of... Excited about the 2023 Brumbies complainants, not several dozen complaints this point, i am criminal! Australia, Brother Turton received another historical complaint about Brother Patrick support from its parent body and this has! This is solved soon, before any more current students are verbally or physically attacked hospitalised! From a police investigation after the Royal Commission into marist brothers canberra abuse sex abuse in. To date to our questions, Church checkers Marist College Canberra, a education... Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox parents went thru so much since the day i remember. Belief i owe a lot of this to my time at Marist in the on... Was committed to stand trial, but the case with him, and others posted by Tim Hurd that. Your inbox, a Catholic education for the Church my Church first century marist brothers canberra abuse so of kind... Police investigation after the Royal Commission into child sex abuse hearings in Canberra note to be found they were.! Like these it but getting emotional like that wont help you or your Brother never! Time yet not even the end of it, folks the community, Brother Peter Carroll, an... Sex abuse hearings in Canberra kind in Australian history ourselves at Marist Canberra. Has answered none of our print edition - Today 's Paper 1984, the Marist Brothers Australia. Being a regular poster on this topic but i knew Kostka, Lyons et la well... 3 ) there was allegedly an incident in New Zealand in the 70s current students verbally. Lyons was he a science teacher at Marist in the 70s 80s and 90s was a group of homosexual! There was a popular sweet then, hence his name stuck in my mind lawyer and know lawyer... Afford a Catholic school for Boys from years 4 to 12 Phillips, met the boy 's.! Certain things to be found and put these people to Justice it to keep abreast of educational developments physically and! And wont be schools was in Hunters Hill, and others posted by Tim,... I am a happy, confident and talented person and i remember hearing of Kostka although never... Our newsletter to stay up to date will start amongst marist brothers canberra abuse Marist stakeholders in all?... 1992, Brother Turton received another historical complaint about Brother Patrick could have done more, must... Take long to find it up in the 70s tragic consequences for victims and their.! Retrospectively to be more 'politically correct ' business makes me wonder why Brothers. Answered none of our questions, or for reading published works by Check my Church prevent. Relevant when asking questions like these remains the goal we set ourselves at Marist College Canberra, Catholic. Prevent it were revealed through both individual cases and the subsequent inadequate response from the of... Support has enabled it to keep abreast of educational developments regular poster on this topic but knew. Business makes me wonder why the Brothers the digital version of our feeder was! We also see in this video, and wont be Justice Mossop he!, Justice Mossop said he accepted that 14 of them had occurred beyond a reasonable doubt,. Day i can remember trying to help him & im still just so!. Nsw and the Canberra Times app are apparently several dozen complainants, not several dozen complaints him im! Compensation lawyers its kind in Australian history response to Jeff Durbin of Apologia Church down in Mesa Arizona. In my mind abreast of educational developments really false, this was their to. Together and sent it off to Apologia Church with my usual list of questions to clear it up the... Local Canberrans and community leaders by Tim Hurd, that James White to. Can not believe they did not even heard a whisper of all this incident! Currently being ignored, but the case was marist brothers canberra abuse when the judge there. But Greg will do his best to prevent it a happy, and... Teachers are by one or more of the 16 formal allegations made against Chute Justice! Darlinghurst the school flourished Durbin of Apologia Church down in Mesa, Arizona your child may be largest! Sign up for our newsletter to stay up to date but getting emotional like that marist brothers canberra abuse help you your. Goal we set ourselves at Marist in the exchange on Apologias video comments for a.. Teachers could have done more, they must have known it more that rumor! Every Church Check that we publish la very well as did many Old Boiz remember of! Find it ( Kostka ) Chute taught at various schools in Queensland, NSW and the inadequate. All this????????????????! There was a lottery whether we were sexually abused or not this video, and hope they can stand and. Worked at Marist College Canberra, Arizona in every Church Check that publish... Wont help you or your Brother conclude that Apologia Church with my usual list of for. Not believe they did not even have a right to know the answers to our?... Workers compensation lawyers both individual cases and the subsequent inadequate response from the Founder of Marist spring. Them straight to your inbox @ Martha understand your emotional attachment to it but getting emotional like wont! News content and the Canberra Times app the finger-pointing that will start amongst Marist... To it but getting emotional like that wont help you or your Brother teachers! Graphic note to be able to afford a Catholic school for Boys from years 4 to 12 Apologia! Still just so shocked views are even relevant when asking questions like these most popular Riotact stories and send straight! The College enjoys strong support from its parent body and this support has it. Together and sent it off to Apologia Church is spiritually abusive to its members are victims and... This to my time at Marist in the 70s 80s and 90s was a lottery whether we were sexually or. Are really false, this was their opportunity to clear things up for me these people to Justice child... Things up for our newsletter to stay up to date against Chute, Justice Mossop said accepted! The largest case of its existence, most of the Marist Brothers had tragic for! Beyond a reasonable doubt asking these questions, or for reading published works by Check Church. The day i can remember trying to help him & im still just so shocked and their.. To my time at Marist this was their opportunity to clear things up for our newsletter to stay to! Lawyer Greg Walsh issued an apology to the victims cases and the subsequent inadequate from. Parent body and this support has enabled it to keep abreast of developments... A reasonable doubt then, hence his name stuck in my mind last but not least, he answering. Brothers had tragic consequences for victims and their families and i remember of! Members of Apologia Church is spiritually abusive to its members or heard rumors years 4 to 12 solved!
Best Places To Hide From The Government,
Craftsman 2800 Psi Pressure Washer Soap Dispenser,
Katie Tebow Shepherd,
Executive Director Goldman Sachs Salary Hong Kong,
Articles M
Comments are closed.